Lake Monticello, VA Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Lake Monticello house for sale by the water
Looking for lakefront living near Charlottesville? Welcome to Lake Monticello—an amenity-rich, gated community nestled in the heart of Virginia’s Piedmont region. With its 352-acre lake, championship golf course, and family-friendly atmosphere, Lake Monticello offers the perfect blend of natural beauty, recreational lifestyle, and suburban convenience. At Matthias John Realty, we help homebuyers, vacation seekers, and investors explore opportunities in this unique Fluvanna County community—just 25 minutes from downtown Charlottesville and within easy reach of Richmond. Contact Matthias at (434) 906‑4630 or fill out the form below to schedule your private tour of homes in Lake Monticello, VA.

Why Live in Lake Monticello?

Lake Monticello isn’t just a place—it’s a lifestyle. Residents enjoy scenic lake views, private beaches, and a tight-knit community atmosphere all within a secure, HOA-managed setting. It’s ideal for:
  • Families looking for safe, active neighborhoods
  • Retirees seeking recreation and serenity
  • UVA staff and Charlottesville commuters
  • Investors targeting vacation and short-term rental properties
Whether you’re boating at sunset or hosting friends on your back deck, life at Lake Monticello feels like a permanent getaway.

Community Amenities & Features

1. Private Lake Access

The 352-acre lake is the community’s centerpiece, perfect for:
  • Boating, kayaking, and paddleboarding
  • Water skiing and wakeboarding
  • Fishing and wildlife watching
  • Five sandy beaches, each with picnic areas and lifeguards in season

2. Championship Golf Course

  • Designed by Russell Breeden
  • 18 holes, rolling fairways, and scenic lake views
  • Full-service pro shop, lessons, and tournaments

3. Clubhouse & Marina

  • Community clubhouse with restaurant and event space
  • Full-service marina with slips for lease or purchase
  • Boat rentals, maintenance services, and on-site fuel station

4. Additional Amenities

  • Tennis and pickleball courts
  • Outdoor swimming pools and playgrounds
  • Basketball courts and baseball fields
  • Scenic walking trails and nature paths
  • Dog parks and community gardens
This variety of recreational offerings ensures there’s something for everyone, from toddlers to retirees.

Real Estate Market Overview

Lake Monticello real estate offers a wide range of properties to suit different budgets and lifestyles. With approximately 4,200 homes in the community, you’ll find:

Lakefront Homes

  • Private docks, panoramic views, and premium prices
  • Wraparound porches, decks, and boathouses
  • High demand for both resale and rental investment

Golf Course Homes

  • Beautiful views of fairways and greens
  • Easy access to tee times and golf cart paths
  • Often include large windows, patios, and mature landscaping

Interior Lots & Homes

  • More affordable options with access to all amenities
  • Larger wooded lots and private yards
  • Great value for first-time buyers and families

New Construction & Renovated Homes

  • Energy-efficient systems and smart home tech
  • Contemporary design blended with rustic charm
  • Open layouts, chef’s kitchens, and spa-style primary suites
Median home prices hover around $350,000, with lakefront homes commanding higher premiums. Inventory remains competitive, so early preparation is key.

Location & Accessibility

One of Lake Monticello’s biggest advantages is its proximity to Charlottesville and surrounding cities:
  • 25 minutes to UVA and Downtown Charlottesville
  • 1 hour to Richmond via I-64
  • Close to Zion Crossroads, Palmyra, and Scottsville

Commuting & Travel

  • Easy access to Route 53, Route 15, and Interstate 64
  • Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport (CHO) just 35 minutes away
  • High-speed internet available for remote workers
Residents enjoy small-town living without sacrificing access to major employment hubs, hospitals, and universities.

Schools & Education

Lake Monticello is served by Fluvanna County Public Schools, which are known for their strong academic performance and student-focused instruction. Nearby schools include:
  • Central Elementary School
  • Fluvanna Middle School
  • Fluvanna County High School
Several Charlottesville-based private schools are also accessible within a 30–40 minute drive. In addition, the University of Virginia is a major regional resource for continuing education and cultural enrichment.

Community Life & Events

Living in Lake Monticello means being part of an active, welcoming community with something always on the calendar.

Events include:

  • Fourth of July fireworks and summer concerts
  • Holiday boat parades and beach parties
  • Golf tournaments and tennis socials
  • Book clubs, fitness classes, and art groups
The Lake Monticello Owners’ Association ensures the community stays clean, safe, and connected through responsible management, organized events, and resident involvement.

Investment Potential

Lake Monticello is increasingly popular with buyers seeking:
  • Second homes or vacation rentals
  • Investment properties for short-term Airbnb income
  • Long-term appreciation and low vacancy risk
With high seasonal demand from Charlottesville-area visitors and Richmond weekenders, the neighborhood supports a vibrant short-term rental market. Rental-friendly HOA policies and high guest satisfaction make Lake Monticello an attractive asset for investor portfolios.

Healthcare & Services

Lake Monticello residents have access to:
  • UVA Medical Center (nationally ranked hospital) – 25 minutes away
  • Local urgent care centers, dental clinics, and specialists
  • Pharmacies, grocery stores, hardware, and gas stations in nearby Palmyra
  • Access to more robust services in Charlottesville and Richmond

Environmental Commitment

The community maintains high environmental standards to preserve the lake’s ecosystem and surrounding wildlife. The HOA enforces regulations on:
  • Dock and shoreline maintenance
  • Runoff and erosion control
  • Landscaping guidelines and wildlife protection
Residents take pride in being stewards of this natural resource.

Ready to Tour Homes in Lake Monticello?

Whether you’re looking for a lakefront cottage, a golf course escape, or a value-driven family home, Lake Monticello offers one of the best lifestyle and investment combinations in Central Virginia. At Matthias John Realty, we provide personalized guidance, local expertise, and proven strategies to help you buy or sell confidently in this competitive market. Call Matthias today at (434) 906‑4630 or complete the contact form below to begin your Lake Monticello real estate journey.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lake Monticello Real Estate

What is the average price of homes in Lake Monticello?

Most homes range from $275,000 to $600,000, with lakefront properties commanding higher premiums.

Is Lake Monticello a gated community?

Yes. It is a private, gated community with HOA management, security patrols, and resident-only amenities.

Can I buy a home with private lake access?

Yes. Lakefront homes often include docks and private access for boating and swimming.

Is short-term renting allowed in Lake Monticello?

Short-term rentals are permitted, subject to HOA regulations and Fluvanna County ordinances.

How far is Lake Monticello from Charlottesville?

Roughly 25 minutes by car, making it a popular choice for UVA employees and Charlottesville commuters.
Skip to content